Dinah: Welcome to Farm to School Northeast, a podcast where we explore the creative ways that local food is getting into school cafeterias and how food system education is playing out in classrooms and school gardens across the Northeast. Today, we have an opportunity to sit down with students from the Springfield Renaissance School in Springfield, Massachusetts. Renaissance is part of the EL education network of schools whose focus, among other things, is to provide students with immersive and meaningful learning expeditions that connect students with real world issues. Last school year, ninth grade students were able to successfully phase out styrofoam trays across Springfield Public Schools as part of their sustainability expedition. This year, the current ninth grade class has continued that work by tackling food waste. They have instituted a commercial composting program at Renaissance and are collaborating with district leaders to expand the program across other schools in the district next year.
Thanks so much for inviting me to your school to talk. I'm so happy to be here. Can each of you introduce yourself to our listeners and then can one of you give us an overview of your student team?

Jocelyn: My name is Jocelyn.

Edwin and Aidan: My name is Edwin. My name's Aiden.

Maddie, Michaela and Kaylee: My name is Maddie. My name is Michaela. My name is Kaylee.

John Donovan: And my name's John Donovan. I'm the ninth grade environmental science teacher at Renaissance.

Jocelyn: We are a group of representatives from the ninth grade who worked on the composting expedition.

Dinah: So I know it was a few years ago, but before we get to the current work of food waste reduction, could someone speak about compostable trays and your compostable tray initiative? How did that start and what was the end result in your school district?

Maddie: This is Maddie. It was a whole process. We did a lot to get to where we are now. We wrote letters to Homegrown Springfield and our principal and Sodexo, a whole bunch of letters. And then we made a recycling plan and we kind of tried to teach the school what to recycle, what not to recycle. And then we made a presentation for our superintendent and homegrown Springfield representatives about removing soy from trays in our district. And it worked because Sodexo recognized all of our hard work and they started working with us to get to our goal. And then we met with them and we talked to them about the money aspect and all the other aspects of getting the trays. And then we got the trays and we had a press release with the news where we released the trays officially and we kind of talked about the process.

John: And that was in November of this year. So four or five months after the meeting with the superintendent was when they came back and officially announced that we were getting the trays and that you guys had that awesome press conference.

Dinah: Were you surprised that it worked?

Maddie: I think we started off when everyone came in the first day of school, we were kind of like, "Oh, it's just another class." We were still convinced that we couldn't really make big changes as young people. And then by the end of the year we were like, "Wow, we actually did something pretty big." It was kind of cool. 

Dinah: And that ties into the current trash audit, because all of that was trash. So let's talk about that a little bit. After your success with this compostable tray, I understand that now you're working on the issue of food waste. So can someone walk listeners through how you're doing this? How do you figure out, this is a really large district, right? Mr. Donovan, how big is this? How many schools?

John:  I think it's somewhere around 24 to 25,000 students. And I think our work really just started with how do we make Renaissance a more sustainable school? And that was kind of where everything started. So if somebody wants to start walking through the work that you guys did to get there, that'd be great.

Michaela: My name's Michaela and we started with the trash audit, which was basically picking out trash from the lunch and from other classrooms. And we would sort through it. We would see how much trash there was, how much food, plastics. And we measured the amount of food waste and we estimated to about 80 pounds of food per day. And so in our math class, we calculated how much that would be in a year. And for the school it would be 14,000 pounds per year. And then we did a little bit more math and we decided to find out how much food waste would be in the district. And that was about 700,000 pounds of food waste in the district each year.

Dinah: Wow, that's a lot of computation and that's a lot of weight. Were you surprised by that amount of weight per day?

Michaela: Yeah, there was a lot. It was a lot of food waste and I didn't think it would be that much, especially per day.

Dinah: Was it gross touching all the food, like going through the garbage?

Edwin: Yeah, it was. Especially, I remember that day it was like spaghetti and meatballs, so it was extra disgusting, but we went through it and we did it. And so yeah, we measured the 81 pounds of food waste and from there we went on. From there we actually went to the school committee and we told them about this problem.

Maddie: We wrote a resolution to present to the school committee and we also had to create slideshows to teach them about the issue, show them what we were doing throughout our classes with this project to really get them to notice and understand what we were doing with this issue.

John: One of the things that we found or that when you guys were talking to the school committee was our particular school committee doesn't necessarily vote on resolutions specifically. So we presented all of our findings or you guys presented all of the findings there. And I think one of the big takeaways that we found sitting there was that our school committee was really open to this idea of composting, but they themselves were a little unsure of what the chain of command was, of who would be in charge of enacting this and how things happen. So it was this very organic moment where everybody was like, "Oh, this is a good idea, but how do we actually go about phasing this in and where does that money come from?" And that was kind of a moment where everybody stopped and was like, "Oh, we do need to figure out a little more with this."

Michaela: Yeah. So before going to the school committee, we had a meeting with Commonwealth Sustainability about logistics and how much it would cost for our school and the whole district to get composting. They said it would be about five to six dollars per student in the whole district if we divided it up.

John: And when you looked at the math, really the number was over $100,000 probably per year, at least for the first year to start, but then divided by the number of students, it was like four to six dollars per student per year if everyone in the district had composting.

Dinah: Is that less expensive than the trash? Does it save money for the school? Because you probably had to convince the school committee that this was a financially good idea, right?

Michaela: Yeah. I wouldn't say it would be less, but it would be diverted. So the money that would be going to the trash would now be going to composting.

John: Does somebody want to talk about what is commercial composting? Just a brief summary and why did you all decide that was the route to go to deal with our trash? Why didn't we just let it keep going to a landfill or why did we not send it to a pig farm or some other alternative?

Michaela: Commercial composting is when we send our food waste to a composting company and they compost it and turn it into fertilizer so that we could reuse it. And the reason we didn't want to keep letting it go into landfill is because when it's in a landfill, it creates methane, which is a greenhouse gas, which traps in heat and goes into atmosphere making our planet hotter and all of that comes climate change. And so we wanted to make Renaissance a more environmentally sustainable school. And so that's why we chose commercial composting. There was also other options like a garden, but we have a lot, tons and tons of food waste that we really needed a better efficient way.

Edwin: So my name is Edwin. We also chose commercial composting because with other composting, we couldn't really send everything in there. There were certain things that we couldn't compost, if you could say. And with commercial composting, we could compost pretty much almost everything that would come from the school than the other options. So that's why we also went more with commercial composting.

Dinah: So I got to see the compost area in the cafeteria. Do you want to talk about what it's like to facilitate all the students at your school knowing how to actually do it? Because I think probably the students here were used to just throwing everything out into the garbage and suddenly now they have to be dividing. So what's it like as a student monitor of that?

Michaela: Yeah, it's a big change from how we used to do it because previously we used to bring the trash barrels to the students to throw them away. So now they have to come up to us and compost and throw trash and recycling. So yeah, it's a big change. Monitoring it is not too difficult. I expected it to be a lot harder, but after the first few days, people started to understand what to do, where to put things, and also the signage definitely helped a lot with sorting out the trash. And I think that it's been really good.

John: Michaela, what are your typical responsibilities? During that time, what are you doing?

Michaela: The typical responsibilities I would say is to just see where everything is going, make sure that nothing is getting in the wrong area, specifically the composting bin because that's our main focus. So if any plastic goes into there, that's not good. But everything else, we can still monitor and see what's going in where.

Dinah: So this year, the composting company, Commonwealth, gave you the bins to get started and they're picking it up and they're just doing it all just to get you going.

John: Yeah. As someone who's worked with students and seen students talk to and interact with adults and organizations and companies, I can't shout out Matt and Steve are the two owners of Commonwealth Sustainability. They were really inspired by the work that all the students were doing and they said that they didn't want the financial barrier to postpone them getting started. So they said rather than have to wait for all of the hoops to kind of be jumped through to get composting started, they said, "We'll offer you just free composting for the rest of the school year so that you guys can get this going and then we'll figure out for next year how we'll pay for it and how we'll roll this out to other schools." So that was really incredible and I just don't think we can thank them enough for that because I don't know that we would be in this position right now without them.

Dinah: Making systemic change, obviously we know it can be really hard. You're in a really large school district and you're one school in a district and you're looking at changing this entire city and how it operates. And I imagine you faced some obstacles along the way. So what were some of the biggest obstacles you've had to overcome and how did you all keep this project moving forward?

Aiden: So my name's Aiden and the main challenges that we've personally seen was finding the main logistics and students not caring to compost, which is happening right now since they just leave their trays on the lunch table and they're just too lazy to get up and then sort it. And then the other thing that we also did, which was a challenge, was finding companies to collaborate with, which is Commonwealth Sustainability. And then they also had other ones and we just didn't know which one to choose.

John: Let me ask this. What percentage of trays or of students do you think are successfully coming up and they're taking care of their composting? Where would we put that at?

Aidan: I'd say around 70% are actually being fully successful.

Michaela: Yeah. I think around that number, maybe even higher, definitely majority are composting.

John: Yeah, I agree with you. I think it is a vast majority. I would probably just put it at around 90%. I think we sometimes notice the five or six or seven little groups of people that aren't doing it and it's frustrating because you're like, why aren't they doing that? But then the end of lunch, you guys have this massive stack of compostable trays of all of the students that are doing it right.

Dinah: So as you move this project forward next year, what are some ways you're going to get those 10% of high school students of your peers to maybe get on board a little more? Do you have any strategies for that?

Jocelyn: Yeah. So at the beginning when we first started the composting, there was a lot of people working it and every time somebody came up, we flapped for them and we just made it a big thing. And I think that helped people want to come up and compost because it made it kind of fun. So I think if we continue to do that, it'll make it seem like not such a chore for people to do, just making it seem fun.

Michaela: Maybe like a training for students, like a slideshow, just showing people what to do, where to put stuff. Even though we do have the signage, I think that making a slideshow to tell people where to go is also really important.

John: Just for schools and people that are trying to replicate this, I think it is important to kind of call back to the fact that we have trained some of our high school students for five or six years. Do not get out of your seat. We'll come to you and we'll grab your trash. And so are some students not doing it because they're feeling lazy and don't want to get up? Yes, probably, but we kind of taught them to do this. And so I think to be really clear about whatever structure your school has, if it's going to be a different strategy to really emphasize with the students, "Hey, we know we used to do it this way. Now we're doing it this different way." And being really clear about that, which I don't know that maybe I think we could have been more clear with our students as a whole, we're shifting how we're doing things. I think it's good to address that with your students.

Dinah: What advice do you have for students in other schools to create positive change and tackle issues that might seem really large and unchangeable?

Jocelyn: I would tell them that when making changes like we did in our composting expedition, I would tell them to remember that their voice matters and that student voices are what people want to hear to make change. I would tell them to take initiative and to focus on creating and following a plan and most importantly to not give up because it is going to be a very long process. However, it's going to be achievable and with hard work and consistency, you can get what you really want to achieve.

Maddie: And also creating a big support system because obviously you can do it by yourself, but also having that group of people to help you is really important in getting something because it can make your voice louder knowing that there's people there with you to help you.

Jocelyn: I also think you should never think a problem is too big to try to tackle because if you start it and don't finish it, you're still doing something because somebody could pick it up and then just tackle it and complete it and achieve the things that you want to achieve. So a problem or something, a problem's never too big. You should never think of it as too big.

Dinah: So Mr. Donovan, you clearly make room for student voice. So I would ask you, as someone who's working with students, what would you tell other teachers who might want to support students to do this kind of social change?

John: Yeah. I do want to acknowledge that one of the reasons why we've been able to do so much of this work over the last two years in working in with EL education, which is our school model, which they're amazing and they really emphasize doing this work as part of the curriculum, not as an afterschool club that works for 30 minutes once a week. And so I don't think we would be able to achieve anything on the scale that we have without being able to do it in the classroom with the 80 students that I see every day. So finding ways to work it into your curriculum, but also to collaborate with the other teachers on your team. We had students read about tons of food waste issues and also food insecurity and things that I couldn't necessarily get to in the science classroom because of other content that they were learning about there.
We had tons of math and extrapolating data and all these things that were super important for our school committee meetings and everything that again, would be hard for me to get to in addition to teaching all the science stuff. But then our math teacher said, "I'll come in and we'll do a couple lessons on this and we'll analyze the data." So really leveraging the other people on your team. And there's just so many community members that are in organizations whose goal is to work with students, but they have trouble finding groups of students to get in front of them. And so to be able to just do a little bit of reaching out and then it snowballs and then you will get to a point where you might have to tell a group like, "I'm sorry, we can't come to your conference or your meeting and thing that you have because we're doing this other thing." People really just want to get involved with students.
But really to get to Maddie's point, I think is kind of at the heart of it is to really just to trust your students and their ability to do something and start with something big and start with a question like, how do I make my school more sustainable? Not how do I make sure that I have a compost program by the end of the school year? So just a big goal and working towards it. And yeah, I think that it sounds very overwhelming when you hear it all laid out, but once you get into the work, it's just like, "Well, if I was an adult solving this problem, what would I do next? How can I, instead of doing that, prepare kids to do that and then the next step and how do I make sure that kids are figuring out how to do this?" And then yeah, really awesome things tend to happen.

Dinah: So what's next for your group and how do you hope to continue this work and make it grow?

Maddie: I would say that what is next is to expand it to other schools in the district, but to do that, we really need the help of all the change makers, all the principals, all the people working in the schools, in school communities. And I also want to give a reminder that we're one of the first schools in the SBS who tries to get composting for a school and we were able to do it, so can other schools do it, too.

Dinah: Just to close out this conversation, can you each share why this activism is so important to you?

Michaela: To me, it's important because it's my future. It's my sibling's future. It's my generation's future. And I feel like if we don't do something about what is going on right now, no one will. We're dealing with the consequences of the past generations and I don't want that to lay down on the generations coming after us. So I feel like we have to do something about the environment and help out.

Edwin: This is important to me because I love the nature and I feel like we're losing it every so often now as all of this is going on with climate change and everything. So I really think that this could make an effect and probably inspire other people to do the same and want to make change to a positive future. And like Kaylee said, it's not only our future, it's our siblings and the other generations to come future. And we want them to be able to enjoy also what we are able to enjoy with the nature and our planet.

Aidan: Well, in my opinion, activism's important to me because it essentially allows people to advocate against important issues that affect them now rather than issues from before and then it can also affect the future.

Jocelyn: I think it's important to show our generation that we can actually make change. We have the power to use our voice and that's just important to remember.

Maddie: Yeah. I'd like to agree with Kaylee and I'd like to say that we are the future and that we are young and we have so much ahead of us. And I think that we should make this change now, that we should use our voices that we're young and we can be able to do things even though we may seem like we're young and we're not powerful. So I think that we should be using our voices.

Jocelyn: This is important because we recognize the changes that need to be made and we are the ones that can make these changes and we just need students to recognize that we are the change makers that can bring different changes to our schools and to our community.

John: I think being a teacher is so much more than teaching content. And the more that I teach, the more that I realize how much of an opportunity there is to lift up student voices and get students inspired and the things that you think are important. But I've also realized as I get older that adults and people, decision makers, we're stubborn and we're set in our ways and we tend to not always want to listen to each other, but when students and young people speak up, that's when people really listen and that's when things really get done. So I think just to other teachers out there to really provide your students opportunities to use their voice creates a lot more change than the same amount of adults doing it.

Dinah: Well, thanks everyone for taking time. I'm so inspired. I'm leaving your school so inspired and excited. And I've been watching through the paper and the media what you're all doing. And so you definitely are visible change makers and really inspiring. And thank you for all your work and I'm going to keep watching and stay connected to this program as you spread it through the district. Thank you.

John: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you so much for coming.

Dinah: This podcast is a production of the Northeast Farm to School Collaborative. For more information about this podcast or Farm to School in the Northeast, go to northeastfarmtoschool.org.